34 South Main St., Attleboro, MA - Directions - (508) 222-7000
Home News Sports Features classifieds milestones services photos tvlistings cars jobs realestate subscribe
News

Wheaton students see response over the top




NORTON - The governor was up in arms. The mayor threatened legal action. And the assistant attorney general insisted there was malice.

But a day after Boston was temporarily paralyzed when authorities mistook a guerrilla marketing campaign for a potential terrorist attack, some Wheaton students thought the official response to the episode exceeded the boundaries of reason.

"I don't think it's appropriate to sue; I think it's an over-reaction," sophomore Amanda Chomicz said while dining at the campus cafeteria. "If the company issued an apology, that should be good enough."

Students' familiarity with an advertisement-saturated atmosphere, which includes viral, digital, street and guerrilla marketing tactics, is partly responsible for the tenor of its response, Wheaton senior Gate Gannon suggested.

"I can understand people in the older generation being concerned," Gannon said, "but it's an overreaction." Gannon also said the government's response was connected to a heightened atmosphere of tension: "9-11 is definitely a factor," she said. "Everything seems to be in a state of high alert now."

For other students, the fiasco over the marketing stunt raised questions about constitutional issues.

"It's a blatant violation of the freedom of speech," sophomore Sam Brown said of the city's attempts to recoup $750,000 spent on police operations. "It's not the company's fault someone misunderstood their message."

His friend and fellow sophomore Alex Banduzian agreed, saying it was bad policy to make a company pay for such a misunderstanding.

Banduzian said that living in a post- 9-11 environment did not justify an extreme reaction.

"It's a pretty stupid excuse," he said.

Not all students, however, faulted the government's response.

"To be honest, with the state not knowing what was going on, I was pretty proud they took it seriously," said Peggy Shannon-Baker, a senior at the school.

"I think the company should pay whatever it cost to take (the signs) down," she said.

 


*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
View Comments » No comments posted. « Hide Comments

dan.k wrote on Feb 2, 2007 2:10 PM:

" These are some great comments (in the blog, right here, not the Wheatonians or Wheeties, or whatever they are called, maybe Weenies.) by thoughtful people who understand the reality of the life we live, in the crosshairs of the Islamo-fascists. As for this incident, who is going to repay the family of a person who died in transit to the hospital because the traffic system was closed down. Anyone at Wheaton want to venture a guess?? Huh? Come on now. Who will give back the life taken by this terror causing prank. The 1st amendment is not a suicide pact. "

Need more info wrote on Feb 2, 2007 12:14 PM:

" Would someone please consult their friends at Wheaton as to what we should do about global warming, terrorism and the war in Iraq. Oh and where is Osama hiding? The reason we can't get anything done in this world is because the people with all the answers are sitting in the Wheaton cafeteria. "

Why ask them wrote on Feb 2, 2007 10:37 AM:

" This is an example of lazy reporting. Why ask Wheaton students what they think? They weren't directly affected. They sit there in the idylic little country campus sipping lattes and commenting on the world. Why not ask people who were there and affected? Ask students at BU, Harvard, Northeastern, etc. These are the ones who may have missed a class, lab or paper deadline because thet were caught up in this. Personally, I'm sorry I missed chem class professor, but I'm not sorry that the MSP bomb squad takes their job and the safety of the people seriously. I hope those Wheaties grow up to get nice jobs where life and death decisions aren't made. "

PLease move into the real world -- wrote on Feb 2, 2007 9:08 AM:

" Freedom of speech does not mean there is no consequence to your action. There are the old saws about yelling fire in a crowded theater or your right to swing your arm ends where my nose begins. This goes beyond those principles. Companies do not have a right to post a billboard or sign wherever they please. Those temporary signs at highway exits are illegal. Companies like Turner Broadcasting has every right to advertise as long as they follow the rules and regulations that are in place. They did not have the right to violate zoning laws by planting their signs where ever they please on private and public property. (This extends to the vandals who spray paint guerrilla ads). As for the reaction - Boston and Mass State cops have been dealing with bombs planted for various reason since the anarchists back in the 1920s. These devices followed the instruction manuals for planting IEDs. 1. they looked harmless, even attractive 2. they were planted where they could cause the most disruption (look at a map). When these were first reported the police had no way to tell if they were explosive, pyrotechnic (designed to give off smoke) , nuclear or even biological. Some could also have been decoys with others that would have been dangerous. The response was prudent. I also don't accept letting TBS off the hook by paying merely a million dollars. They got more than a million dollars in free publicity. If they were really sorry they would stop all promotion of the cartoon for 90 days and suspend broadcast of the cartoon for 90 days. Yeah, like that would happen. "

newt wrote on Feb 2, 2007 8:47 AM:

" what a beautiful thing it is to be a college student and live and study in an insulated community where tenured professors pontificate about ideals and philosophy. What about the thousands of people who were negatively affected by this prank. Who pays the bill for the forces who were mobilized to investigate? Not these students, more likely their parents and people like me. "

William Carr wrote on Feb 2, 2007 2:43 AM:

" Young Mr. Banduzian called it a misunderstanding! How quaint! Such insight to the world we live in. Stay in school young man and learn something before you open your uneducated mind and be forced to change feet again. His comments are typical of the young idealistic and therefore liberal mind that is yet to be seasoned with real life experience. Grow up young man! "


*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
 or