News
KP to Brown: Apologize
Top Headlines The near-unanimous vote followed lengthy discussion at Monday's school committee meeting by committee members, their student representative and teachers. Brown, R-Wrentham, spoke at a gathering Thursday, singling out several students by name who he said wrote critical comments about him and his family on the Web site, facebook.com. An angry Brown read the comments, some which contained profanities and referred to Brown's anti-gay marriage stance, according to those who attended the assembly. Brown, who handed out printouts of the comments, later said he was defending his family and making a point that only lasted about two minutes into a talk about the Legislature and other topics. But some students had a different view of the assembly, claiming that Brown's comments caused some of the students to cry. Brown did apologize to Superintendent Richard Robbat and Principal Elaine Hanson, but school board members wanted more of an apology. Committee member Pat Francomano initially said he felt that verbal apology was sufficient. However, committee member Maureen Howard pushed for a letter to be sent to Brown asking for a formal apology. Others agreed. "We deem his actions inappropriate, and we wouldn't allow anyone to do it," Howard said. "It shouldn't be from an invited guest. It shouldn't be unreasonable to ask" for an apology. Committee member John Olivieri said he was appalled at the situation. He voted against the measure. "He is an intelligent person. You expect that he would have behaved a little better," he said. "Apologize to our students, apologize to school officials. There were 100 students sitting in the auditorium subject to the same thing," committee member Margaret Billian said. "We need to ask him for a public apology to our staff, students and administrators." Billian said she read comments online and found they were "not nearly as damning as I thought they would be." Howard praised teachers for how they handled the situation, one who tried to cut Brown off. "I think a lot of students were definitely affected. Some students took it a lot more personally than other students," said Hannah Guild, the student representative to the school board. Of an apology, Guild added she thinks students would appreciate it and have a higher opinion of Brown. Edie Erickson, a history teacher, and Jan Rumsey, an adjustment counselor, spoke at the onset of the meeting, with Erickson reading a letter addressed to Brown from the teachers association, looking for a public apology to students. "The circumstances surrounding your appearance at King Philip made it an unwelcome intrusion that served only to disrupt the school day and cause confusion and distress among our students," Erickson said, adding the use of profanity and naming of students "constituted an inexcusable act of public humiliation that violated the norms of acceptable conduct in a place of learning." School committee members also discussed drafting guidelines to hand to guest speakers in the future. "We should do everything possible so it doesn't happen again," committee member Caron Ketchum said. Francomano disagreed, calling it a "single incident where someone made an error in judgement." School board member Beth Gilbert countered Brown "should be aware of appropriate behavior in this setting." Howard also wants school administrators to touch base with the students who reportedly posted the comments.
Post Your Comments kpstudent wrote on Feb 13, 2007 8:30 PM: " King Philip Regional High School is a very special place. It is a place to learn and grow as young adults. If there is a time to make mistakes, it is at this time in my life I hope to make them. Sometimes they are big mistakes, sometimes they are small but always they are learning experiences. It is in this way that the students of KP, myself included, blossom into responsible and successful adults. Those you see as ignorant punks, trouble makers, and good-for-nothings will one day be making important decisions, not to mention paying for your social security. Perhaps the most inspiring thing about the King Philip community is the teachers. These people have dedicated their lives and careers to shaping us; the future of America. We are lucky to have this amazing group as guides on our journey. It hurts me deeply to see the way KP has been portrayed recently in the news. It is as if the whole school is corrupted by the actions of a select few. Actions that inevitably lead to lessons; lessons learned through experience and not force- maybe the best kind. Truth is, KP is not people, it is not a place. You can’t plot KP on a map. That’s because KP is so much bigger than a thing- it is an idea. KP is warrior pride. KP is green and gold. KP is building for our future. So next time when you go to point fingers, (if you are in the business of pointing fingers,) you can place your blame on the people involved, or cry your frustration with the situation. But please, don’t blame KP… because really, KP is a very special place. " One Father Speaks wrote on Feb 13, 2007 6:33 PM: " A few words for Mr. Brown. He and his family chose their lives. With his blessings, every step, every fundraiser, every public appearance was duly noted in all media. He and his entire family have embraced celebrity status and all it entails. Not one member is mentioned without a celebrated description of the others. His over-reaction to the words of children - regardless of their nature - is beyond belief. May he enjoy his notariety, and leave our children alone. " Onesadparent wrote on Feb 13, 2007 6:08 PM: " I agree Scott blew his cool. But the school committee has a responsibility to look into what the students have been exposed to in that school. This has been going on for at least a year with this teacher and apparently the superintendant has known about this. My neighbors daughter had this teacher last year and she was often upset about what he would say and was afraid to speak up. I don't so much blame the kids who wrote those things, but the adults who allow this kind of atmosphere. KP has changed significantly the last couple of years - and not for the better. I just hope that they can get back to teaching school there and keep the politics out. It is still a good school academically, but something has to happen with the administration. " Stand Up for Children wrote on Feb 13, 2007 4:39 PM: " I think that History Teacher Erickson eloquently articulated Brown's unwelcome intrusion at King Philip. Only those who cherish and understand children, and who support their developmental process, can even begin to understand the breadth and ramifications of Brown's abuse of his position. Apparently this senseless and irrational behavior follows when an inherently flawed ego is allowed too much license over legislating others' lives. Apologize,Brown, Apologize! " Applauds KP School Committee wrote on Feb 13, 2007 3:35 PM: " There is something sick about a purported leader who's obsessed with the gender of those who wish to pledge their love with marriage vows. There's something lacking in a middle-aged man who's forgotten the childhood rhyme about "sticks and stones may break my bones but names will never hurt me," and publicly demeans children in their schoolroom. Highest Regards to the KP School Committee for recognizing that Brown's behavior breached all bounds of human decency. " CS wrote on Feb 13, 2007 3:21 PM: " All of you people above should be asshamed about what you wrote. Scott did not act like an adult-he lowered his standards to a teenager-they should say sorry-but so should he-he is in politics-where people are critical-I respect him for "protecting" his family -but that is where it ends. He did not think-there were kids there who were not involved and had to listen to his outrage. Shame on the Senator " DFox wrote on Feb 13, 2007 3:12 PM: " I agree! I still have the highest regard for Sen. Brown. I am so sick of face book - my space and cocky teen attitudes. Seems as though the teenagers are in control and adults are in fear of them. Parents are too concerned about upsetting their child or making them unpopular with their peers when they should be focusing on proper behavior instead of the 'online -anything goes' attitudes. Brown had every right to defend himself and his family and would be lacking as a parent if he did not. " sot wrote on Feb 13, 2007 3:07 PM: " That’s a great way to teach our children responsibility, make inappropriate comments and the King Philip teachers; administration and even the school committee will protect you from being held responsible for your actions. And if someone does take you to task, or tries to hold you responsible for your actions we will make them apologize to you. Is King Philip a high school or kindergarten? Stop coddling, and start teaching these boys & girls to be responsible young adults. Thank you Senator for calling out those who act in such a careless manor and holding them responsible, KP should take a lesson from you, you are teaching lessons for the real world. " S.C. wrote on Feb 13, 2007 2:12 PM: " It seems to me that King Philip and it's students can dish it out but can't take it. Sen. Brown does not owe any apologies to anyone for holding true to his convictions. If these individuals do not agree with the senator on his political views, then they should be sophisticated enough to learn how to express themselves in a responsible manner. This is what the student's parents and King Philip should be teaching. " Jim wrote on Feb 13, 2007 2:03 PM: " A couple of key points: 1.) The students made their comments in an entirely different forum. What's said on the internet isn't always appropriate for a school environment. Scott Brown should recognize that. 2.) Scott Brown should be able to take the high road in this type of situation, rather than retaliate at a school function. These aren't political opponents he attacked; they're children, many of whom are not of voting age. What did he stand to gain? " KP wrote on Feb 13, 2007 1:37 PM: " I just hope we don't need Senator Brown's help in the future. " R-NA wrote on Feb 13, 2007 1:35 PM: " If Senator Brown had not made the mistake of being a Republican in a left wing state this would not be an issue. If his predecessor had used the same words she would have been praised for being forthright.
Massachusetts really has a double standard when it comes to issues of free speach.
" MV wrote on Feb 13, 2007 1:35 PM: " I'll admit that the vulgurness was not necessary...but good for Sen. Brown for calling those kids out! They cried??? Too darn bad for them, good...I'm glad they were embarassed. I'll bet you that's the last time those kids pull a stunt like that. Shame on KP for making Sen. Brown look like the bad guy, typical of KP really. " gtp wrote on Feb 13, 2007 1:10 PM: " KP is too PC. if they wrote it, and posted it, then they can hear it. brown didn't make it up he read it back to them. the school committe drafting "guidelines" for guest speakers? have they lost their minds? is this america? c'mon people, do you think none of the students ever used those words? brown is a hard worker, he acted as a father/husband first....the way it should be. " maureen wrote on Feb 13, 2007 12:40 PM: " How dare these people demand an apology from Senator Brown. How about DEMANDING one from the high school students that wrote the comments in face book in the first place. Mr. Brown did not call these children names he simply read what they had written about him and his daughter. Excuse me Mrs hanson, how about a suspension for these kids?????? They are the ones that did the original damage. If I was the Senator I would sue the parents for defamation.. " mbg wrote on Feb 13, 2007 12:36 PM: " I couldn't agree more with The Esteemed Gentleman from Massachusetts. It's KP who needs to get over themselves. It's ironic to me that the school is upset Senator Brown repeated the words written by the students of the school. The School should be embarassed by the reprehensible behavior of it's students and ask for an apology from them. " or
|