34 South Main St., Attleboro, MA - Directions - (508) 222-7000
Home News Sports Features classifieds milestones services photos tvlistings cars jobs realestate subscribe
News

KP teacher defends criticism of Brown




WRENTHAM - The social studies teacher who prompted state Sen. Scott Brown's appearance before King Philip students last week admits he went on a "rant" in class one day over the issue of gay marriage, but said he never resorted to profanity or encouraged students to make nasty online comments about legislators, including Brown.

Joe Ferreira, a teacher at King Philip Regional High School, has been at the center of a dispute involving Brown, R-Wrentham.

Brown went to Ferreira's classes last Thursday to rebut the teacher's view on gay marriage, but in the process read profanity-laced comments some students had written about him online.

Brown contends the students and Ferreira were engaging in hate speech and cyber-bullying. The senator also said Ferreira was misusing his position as a teacher to politically influence students.

In a telephone interview Wednesday, Ferreira emphasized he was speaking to The Sun Chronicle as a private citizen and not as a representative of King Philip schools. He said Brown's charges about him are untrue.

Ferreira said he did not know students were writing about him and Brown online, adding he was stunned to hear from Brown that the facebook.com Web page the students were writing on said "Ferreira is god."

The profanity the students used in their postings was inappropriate, Ferreira said, and he said he told them so when he found out.

Ferreira said he never used profanity in the classroom or in his writings about gay marriage.

"Foul language is a poor way to express oneself. The English language is too rich to resort to foul language," he said.

He did admit to using insults in the heat of the moment in e-mails to local legislators, but said they were not profane.

Ferreira said the day after Brown and other legislators voted to put a ban on gay marriage on the 2008 ballot, he went on a "rant" to his students about putting discrimination in the state constitution.

He said he was just being passionate, and was not trying to influence his students.

"The idea that I could influence them politically is as funny to them as it is to me," he said.

Brown, however, said parents contacted him about the teacher "pushing his personal agenda on their children," and misrepresenting his vote. The senator said the student "idol worship" Ferreira, so he is influential to them.

Ferreira said the policy at the high school is to present controversial issues with balance. There was no opposing view at that time.

Brown later contacted the school superintendent to ask for time to address the students.

Ferreira said if Brown had restricted himself to speaking on the legislative process and gay marriage, as he said he would, the session would have been a valuable learning experience for the students.

Instead, he said, Brown's quoting profanity from the facebook Web site and singling out students who wrote about him overshadowed the intended subject matter.

"If he had stuck to explaining why he thinks gay marriage is wrong, it would have been a wonderful learning opportunity," Ferreira said. "Instead, you see what has happened."

What has happened is a week's worth of controversy about Brown reading the profanity, and then defending his actions.

Brown said he was standing up to cyber-bullies and holding students accountable for their words.

He said if he read the comments without the swear words, it would have amounted to censorship.

Brown said he has been flooded with calls and e-mails congratulating him for standing up to the students.

Brown has refused to apologize, but Ferreira said he regrets the whole incident because it has caused the students and the school so much trouble.

He said King Philip is an excellent high school where students accomplish wonderful things.

"Frankly, the kids don't need this and King Philip doesn't need this," he said.

JIM HAND covers politics for The Sun Chronicle. He can be reached at 508-236-0399 or at jhand@thesunchronicle.com.

 


*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
View Comments » No comments posted. « Hide Comments

Dear Allies, wrote on Feb 15, 2007 8:02 PM:

" Over the past few days I’ve been perusing the articles and commentaries about Brown’s indecent behavior toward our young, and feel compelled to write. I shudder reading the posts vindicating his spying, whining, vengeance and malice. Yet mostly I feel incredibly heartened by the many contributions coming from those defending our children, teachers and schools. These were written with candor, caring, compassion and intelligence. In all likelihood those incensed at Brown’s serious boundary breaches beckon from diverse ethnic backgrounds, faiths and lifestyles, yet share a common bond when it comes to recognizing our roles in our children’s lives - to Love, Teach, and Protect them. Brown has scandalized many children with woodshed tactics that are anathema to all we are trying to cultivate in our young, and I’ll do my utmost to assure his tentacles do not reach my kids. "

Anon wrote on Feb 15, 2007 6:39 PM:

" DKM: They don't like when you point out the obvious to them, huh? "

Stephen wrote on Feb 15, 2007 6:27 PM:

" I agree with Bye Bye Brown that pushing political views onto schoolchildren *is* an abuse of power and that Ferreira, who admitted to "ranting" to schoolchildren about homosexual politics, seems to have engaged in inappropriate behavior. Perhaps he ought to be fired. (That was your point, right, Bye Bye Brown?) "

Does he snoop? wrote on Feb 15, 2007 6:21 PM:

" Brown acts like a parent that would snoop around his kids' diaries. "

Joe wrote on Feb 15, 2007 6:13 PM:

" This is addressed to former Wrentham Resident - excellent thought, can you detail how a recall effort would work? How can we get the ball rolling? Glad to help you. "

used to be there wrote on Feb 15, 2007 5:42 PM:

" Good for Senator Brown. It is about time someone stood up to the radicals pretending to be teachers these days. Ferreira should not be a teacher. He is disrespectful of those who disagree with him and a bad example of democracy. To hate and debase those who you disagree with is not an appropriate lesson in school. I am kind of surprised the kids went for the bait, though. Parents had best talk to their kids aobut not getting carried away by the hysteria of radicals. "

HS teacher wrote on Feb 15, 2007 5:22 PM:

" Brown callously disregarded the affects of his actions on the self-esteem of these high school students. "

Former Wrentham Resident wrote on Feb 15, 2007 5:15 PM:

" California is no stranger to removing elected officials from office with recall efforts. Senator Brown's actions should be of serious concern to parents, teachers, students and residents whose freedom of speech has been challenged. I think that it's time Senator Brown stepped down, otherwise concerned citizens should begin a recall effort to unseat him. They do work and are effective to stop abuse of power. "

DKM wrote on Feb 15, 2007 5:09 PM:

" Imagine if Attleboro High had a teacher who personally opposed gay marriage. Suppose this teacher had a history of sending insulting emails to local government officials who were on the other side of this issue. Suppose he continually subjected his students to tirades against the mayor of Attleboro. Hateful diatribes that went far beyond criticism of his political views; that attacked his character; mocking him and his partner. Then, these impressionable students begin to treat the wacko teacher as a cult figure. They create websites dedicated to him, they post angry hateful images of the mayor and his partner...some of them even expressing their desire that he die. Then suppose the mayor saw these threatening hateful messages and images, posted under the students' own names, and publicly pointed them out. You know damn well what would happen. The teacher would have been fired immediately for inciting the students. The students would be vilified for their "hate crimes." The editorial of the Sun Chronicle would be demanding that the teacher and students be held fully accountable for their despicable actions. Rather than being criticized for his actions, the media would be lauding the mayor for his courage in bringing the hateful teacher and students to justice. There would certainly be no demands for the mayor to apologize for causing discomfort and embarassment to the students. "

Bye Bye Brown wrote on Feb 15, 2007 5:08 PM:

" It appears that this paranoid Senator Brown is going down and that's no threat because he did it to himself when he chose to march on KP and verbgally assault the students like the gestapo. Sick man. "

Fed up long ago wrote on Feb 15, 2007 4:41 PM:

" For years Brown has wallowed from full media attention to his classroom visits. The more photo-opportunities the merrier. KP wasn't the first pathetic blunder. Remember last year when he treated disabled chilren (one terminally) with signed photos of Ayla saying, "follow your dreams?" That should have been his last public school visit. "

JO wrote on Feb 15, 2007 4:38 PM:

" We need more teachers like Mr. Ferreira. It is shocking to see how many people don't like teachers or students. They seem to want teachers who bore their kids to tears. "

Erick Lawton wrote on Feb 15, 2007 3:46 PM:

" To the Sun Chronicle: Thank you for posting my previous comment. At least I got one through. I would like to say that adding a comment section makes this website MUCH more interesting. "

Joe wrote on Feb 15, 2007 3:39 PM:

" I've dealt personally with Brown - TRUST ME - the man is arrogant, doesn't like to be challenged and will go to any length to defend himself. "

Erick Lawton wrote on Feb 15, 2007 2:50 PM:

" Ferreira said: "The idea that I could influence them politically is as funny to them as it is to me," Is this for real?! He started this whole deal by preaching his politics to a captive crowd of children. This is what my tax dollars pay for?? To undermine our parenting!!For Shame!!!!By the way, Today the Chronicle has CHOOSEN not to post pro Brown comments from myself and two others here at work. We'll see if they let this one through. "

Ex-Wrentham Resident wrote on Feb 15, 2007 2:41 PM:

" “Remember, always give your best. Never get discouraged. Never be petty. Always remember, others may hate you. But those who hate you don't win unless you hate them. And then you destroy yourself.” —Richard M. Nixon Senator Brown rise above this and don't let them win. I wondered how long before Mrs. Firth would chime in, with her two cents worth. “KP Parent wrote on February 15, 2007 11:47 AM: “Missing! seems to think that Scott Brown and his family were threatened. That is just not true. Those of us from Wrentham remember Sen. Brown's performance as a Selectman. He was often abusive and threatening to people that appeared before that Board. People that were critical of him were even investigated by the Police. Another issue that needs to be recalled is that Scott tried his best to milk the publicity garnered by his daughter on American Idol for himself. I am sure Ayla is a nice girl, but she needs time to grow up and mature. Many of us were disgusted by him promoting her all the time - signing photos at a used car lot and at a Mall. Last Halloween, instead of candy, children that knocked on his door got a coupon to order Alya's CD! Enough! " Her record of vitriolic comments about him and her jealousy is legendary. She disputes his account but offers no proof other than her smugness. Refers to his daughter as a 'nice girl' rather than an adult. "

Been reading these posts wrote on Feb 15, 2007 2:20 PM:

" As a parent of a student who did not post negative comments on Facebook but was upset over the confrontation, I've been reading the Sun Chronicle posts. My guess is that the greater percentage by far are posts against Brown's actions. Politically this was a huge blunder. An apology now could help him. Contined arrogance will be liken to the Kerry Kiss of Political Death. "

Bye Bye Brown wrote on Feb 15, 2007 1:25 PM:

" Pushing your views on a school, singling students out and berating them for expressing their opinions is an abuse of power. Read the Constitution and the Bill of Rights because we do not live under martial law or have a form of goverment where we can intimidate others. The people you represent are your constituents and not your oligarchal subjects. You were elected by the people to be a public servant by the people and you are not a ruler. Attacking a high school student body was wrong and what you did promotes fear. It is un-American and it's Bye, Bye Brown. "

And the emperor will be... wrote on Feb 15, 2007 12:53 PM:

" Mr. Ferreira knows that kids have dynamic minds. Maybe after all Brown too has found common ground with our public schoolchildren. Huh? Yes, it seems like Brown has recognized our kids as worthy opponents. But Brown still acts as if he’s emerged the victor. We’ll know in the next round of voting! "

Pragmatic wrote on Feb 15, 2007 12:50 PM:

" If Mr. Brown felt threatened, he could have spoken with the school principal about the specific postings, after all he was right there in the school office to sign in and out of the building. His other appropriate option would have been to contact the individual student's parents since he had their names and knew the town they lived in. There was no need to waste the classtime of 4 classes of kids just to rail about a few postings. He requested to speak to the classes about the political process, yet the bulk of his talk was on an unrelated subject - that is an abuse of power, and the school deserves an apology from him. For him to doubletalk now and dither on about 'cyber-bullying' is merely an attempt to obscure his inappropriate behavior! "

Brown is history wrote on Feb 15, 2007 12:45 PM:

" Mr. Ferreira, we're seeing history in the making. It must have been shocking to watch Brown in action as he tread on children. I say he's met his Waterloo. Cracked from some cracks, that's for sure. "

Appreciative Parent wrote on Feb 15, 2007 12:26 PM:

" Brilliant teachers recognize that we are shackled when we polarize and perceive only “two” viewpoints. Topics tend to be multifaceted - each point reflecting yet another thought. When a side seeks to grow through domination, it risks a fracture to the whole. All sides flourish each appreciates the presence of others, however unique, they add to the splendor of the whole. Mr. Ferreira sparks thinking, and I am grateful that he’s there for my child and treasures her thoughts and contributions. "

Guy wrote on Feb 15, 2007 12:09 PM:

" Brown was wrong. Kudos to the teacher. "

KP Parent wrote on Feb 15, 2007 11:47 AM:

" Missing! seems to think that Scott Brown and his family were threatened. That is just not true. Those of us from Wrentham remember Sen. Brown's performance as a Selectman. He was often abusive and threatening to people that appeared before that Board. People that were critical of him were even investigated by the Police. Another issue that needs to be recalled is that Scott tried his best to milk the publicity garnered by his daughter on American Idol for himself. I am sure Ayla is a nice girl, but she needs time to grow up and mature. Many of us were disgusted by him promoting her all the time - signing photos at a used car lot and at a Mall. Last Halloween, instead of candy, children that knocked on his door got a coupon to order Alya's CD! Enough! "

The past is relevant wrote on Feb 15, 2007 11:40 AM:

" One tiny word from children, big blasts from Scott! Thank you, Mr. Ferreira, for awakening, inspiring, and encouraging students to seek their full potential, for knowing that we’re still evolving as a species and that history matters so we’re not doomed to allow the witch hunts of the past. The tag and bag forces are hard at work, but our kids are mightier for having withstood the assault. So what if the kids don’t like a politician and so what if they use language ala Gen. Patton in their own domain? They’re too young to vote for who decides how their money is spent, yet they’re old enough to work enough to pay taxes. Someday they’ll see the invasion for what it was, and be stronger for it. They will deeply appreciate their school committee and teachers for risking so much when standing in their truth. And, they will never forget the relevance of Thomas Jefferson’s pledge against tyrants who refused to respect the opinions of others. Never. "

Realist wrote on Feb 15, 2007 11:13 AM:

" Since the parents of these students have abdicated to Hillary's village their responsibilty for raising and disciplining their children then it looks like Senator Brown was doing his duty. "

AnotherParent wrote on Feb 15, 2007 10:28 AM:

" I don't see where this history teacher is apologizing. I do NOT want my son or daughter to have to sit through a years instruction with a teacher who constantly mocks their views and that of their parents. There are ways to discuss controversial issues in class by presenting both sides - not what was going on in Ferreira's classes. "

Run,Scott, Run! wrote on Feb 15, 2007 10:21 AM:

" Rehab would be a good 1st step. He's been running from problems too long. Next would be a return to his modeling career. A perfect balance for all of us, where an empty vessel matters not and only the glitter counts; so profound thoughts may exchange in the classroom, and our youth may seek their expression. "

Liberal Handbook wrote on Feb 15, 2007 10:09 AM:

" Liberals Rules for Free Speech Rule 12 (b) If you agree with the speaker, then the speech is "impassioned". (See Howard Dean, and Jesse Jackson) Rule 12 (c) If you disagree with the speaker the speech is a "rant". Rule 12 (d) If people agree with you on a topic, you are in "consensus". Rule 12 (e) If your opponents agree on a topic, they are in "lockstep". "

Mario S. wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:59 AM:

" Hey leadership, Use your words more carefully if you want to make your point. You said:" A legislative leader would endorse legislation granting all marital rights to two persons, regardless of race, creed, or gender." Did you really mean that a father could marry a son or daughter? How about and adult marrying a willing minor? You know, the voters, thru the legislature, determine the criteria for a State approved marriage. Age, relationship check, blood test,etc. all discriminate between those couples granted a marriage license and those who aren't. If the voters want to change or add a criteria, it is just and legal. It is a right (1st amendment)to petition the government for redress of grievances. If you want homosexual marriage, convince the voters and vote. You cannot say that it isn't equal protection under the law because that would also allow all the others who fail the marriage criteria to use the same arguement, thereby destroying the institution of marriage which is an endorsement of the union of two people as defined by the legislature(the people)......not the courts. "

Think about it wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:55 AM:

" The only threat to Brown was to his ego. The kids didn't invent the f-word --- and they weren't posting on THEIR forum during class time. Brown just wants to SCARE kids SILENT, and that is the only threat in this whole scenario. If Brown spent as much time applauding all the great things KP kids do for their school outside of classes, we'd really be on the map! "

To: "Missing" wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:55 AM:

" His family was NOT threatened. If they were, the police would be involved. What was threatened was Brown's pride. He is a number one type of person. He and his family always has to be number one. It's an adiction. The thought that he wasn't #1 ate at him. Thus he retaliates not to win someone over but to cull them from the herd. Who said something about mental instability??? "

What’s The Big Deal? wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:33 AM:

" I think this whole incident has been blown way out of proportion. I don’t care if a state senator used a cuss word in front of some high school students—show me an American high schooler who hasn’t hear a cuss word. Nor do I care whether a high school teacher is letting his political views seep into classroom discussions—an impassioned teacher should do that to a certain extent. In the grand scheme of things, this incident has little, to no significance. Remember, NO child has been injured by this incident. What the kids have probably learned from this abject lesson is that the media sensationalizes to make a buck and politics is mostly a bunch of hot air. "

Bob H wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:29 AM:

" We've heard apologies from the kids, Mr. Ferreira but not Senator Brown. Another person posted on this forum a question of Brown's mental stability. I say, Senator Brown, sign into rehab. along with Isaiah Washington and Mel Gibson. Maybe then you'll realize how to react appropriately without revenge, anger and retaliation. "

Missing! wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:24 AM:

" Your all missing the point here. The man and his family were threatened. If you or someone close to you were threatened I think you'd have a different outlook on this. He was letting the people that threatened him know who they are, and that they didn't get away with it. They were caught in the act and they didn't like it. "

Dissapointed wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:15 AM:

" My concern is that this is breaking down to a political issue re: gay marraige. We need to view this incident with non-political eyes. I believe the students used a forum of their generation along with language that was entirely inappropriate. Yet, if Mr. Brown agrees that these comments were offensive and inappropriate, then he must be made to realize that his actions were worse - planned embarrassment of individuals, deliberate use of wording he himself was decrying in front of many innocent students and an attitude of arrogance on par with the teens he was attempting to humiliate - not exactly the maturity, understanding and control expected of any adult, especially a role model. "

Saddened wrote on Feb 15, 2007 9:06 AM:

" This teacher said: "The idea that I could influence them politically is as funny to them as it is to me," Is this for real?!? Pushing a political agenda is EXACTLY what the teachers union have been doing for years. Why do you think they give their campaign contributions to the Dems? Answer: to promote their socialist fiscal and moral agenda. "

Appreciate the Teacher wrote on Feb 15, 2007 8:48 AM:

" Here's a no-brainer: If you needed a child-advocate, would you pick a vengeful bigot or a broad-minded, understanding, and compassionate human being? I'm so thankful that Mr. Ferreira celebrates the thread that binds humanity, yet recognizes the unique attributes of each person's path in life...with harm to none. "

Class & Dignity wrote on Feb 15, 2007 8:41 AM:

" Mr. Ferreira has both class and dignity something that is totally lacking in Senator Brown. I voted for Brown in the past but can no longer support a man who resorts to tactics that border on mental instability. After the fact, Mr. Ferreira and the children who were responsible for the negative facebook posts have shown class. Senator Brown has shown arrogance and is at the bottom of the totem pole. "

Leadership needed - wrote on Feb 15, 2007 8:19 AM:

" Frankly, King Philip doesn't need Brown turning a place of learning into a Corrections Facility! A legislative leader would endorse legislation granting all marital rights to two persons, regardless of race, creed, or gender. The Mass. Supreme Judicial Court would interpret the constitutionality of the legislation. If matters of rights - civil or otherwise - were left to the populace, our majority would rule regardless of the rights of the minorities. We'd still have segregation if the majority opinion was all that counted. That's the only way a great republic can guarantee equal justice for all. "

Stephen wrote on Feb 15, 2007 2:04 AM:

" I think it's interesting that the Sun Chronicle describes Ferreira as a "social studies teacher," because WBZ and the MetroWest Daily News have reported that he teaches "history" at KP. I'd say that's an important distinction, and I'd like to know the truth. If Ferreira does in fact teach a "social studies" class, then it may have been appropriate to discuss a significant social issue like gay marriage (although a "rant," as Ferreira describes it, probably crosses a line); but if he's ostensibly teaching history -- or math, or literature, or music appreciation -- then he probably had no business using class time to ruminate on his pet political issue instead of teaching students about the Visigoths, or calculus, or Joyce's Ulysses. "


*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
 or