34 South Main St., Attleboro, MA - Directions - (508) 222-7000
Home News Sports Features classifieds milestones services photos tvlistings cars jobs realestate subscribe
News

Teen in fatal crash held in OUI



Elizabeth Finnegan




Norfolk woman arrested in Ashland
NORFOLK - A Norfolk teenager on probation for a December 2006 fatal hit-and-run accident in Wrentham was ordered into substance abuse treatment Tuesday after a weekend drunk driving arrest in Ashland.

Ashland police allege Elizabeth Finnegan, 19, of 30 Rockwood Drive, was drunk behind the wheel and her car stuck in a snowbank early Sunday morning in Ashland.

She and a friend were slumped against the center console of a car off the road at Oak Street and Whipporwill Lane about 7:40 a.m., Ashland Police Lt. Richard Briggs said.

Police charged Finnegan with driving under the influence of alcohol, being a minor in possession of alcohol, resisting arrest and negligent operation.

The arrest violated Finnegan's probation for the Dec. 21, 2006, hit-and-run accident in which a pedestrian, Jeffrey W. Cardin, 48, of Shears Street in Wrentham, was killed, said Coria Holland, a spokeswoman for the state probation commissioner's office.
Cardin, a father of three from Millis, was walking home from the Anvil Pub in an area with no sidewalks when he was struck about 100 yards from a rooming house where he was staying on Walnut Street in Wrentham.

Finnegan turned herself in to Wrentham police the next day, and told investigators she was driving in that area during the night of the accident and thought she might have hit something.

In the most recent case, Finnegan was ordered into substance abuse treatment and was told to stay away from drugs and alcohol following a detention hearing Tuesday in Wrentham District Court, Holland said.

A probation violation hearing is scheduled for April 3.

Finnegan's attorney, Vanessa Sanchez-Gasparro of Natick, declined to comment.

Finnegan has refused to cooperate with Ashland police since Sunday's incident, Briggs said.

Finnegan "refused to answer any questions" and invoked her right to remain silent at the MetroWest Medical Center in Framingham, where she and passenger Carrie O'Shea, 20, of 158 North St. in Norfolk, were taken by Ashland paramedics for treatment of minor injuries, Briggs said.

Finnegan and O'Shea refused treatment, he said.

The incident began when Ashland police responded to a report of a car off the road with two unconscious women inside, Briggs said.

Investigating officers found Finnegan and O'Shea slumped over the center console of the car, and Finnegan "became combative" as officers and paramedics tried to remove her from the car, Briggs said.
Finnegan had to be restrained on an ambulance stretcher until she calmed down, he said.

She was "incoherent, unable to answer basic questions from the officers, such as her name or date of birth," Briggs said.

Police say they searched the car and found two beer cans, a pint-size bottle of 80-proof E & J brandy about two-thirds empty on the passenger side floorboard, and a tan purse. They also found a small bag holding less than an ounce of alleged marijuana in O'Shea's purse.

The car's transmission was in drive, and the ignition was switched on, Briggs said.

The front passenger side tire was missing and the aluminum rim was flat, indicating the car had "driven on a flat tire for a distance," he said.

At the hospital, Finnegan told police "she couldn't be arrested unless her lawyer was present," Briggs said.

At some point, Finnegan asked to smoke a cigarette.

When she was denied, she "lunged at an officer in an effort to get out of the room," Briggs said.

She was restrained, charged with resisting arrest, then was booked at the Ashland police station.

Finnegan was released without bail following her arraignment Monday in Framingham District Court, a court official said. Her next court date is April 22.

O'Shea, meanwhile, will be summonsed to court to face a charge of minor in possession of alcohol.

Police also cited her for possession of less than an ounce of marijuana, a civil infraction.

 


*Member ID:
*Password:
  Forgot Your Password?
 
View Comments » 44 comment(s) « Hide Comments

goodman wrote on Apr 5, 2009 12:56 AM:

" Looks like the joker "

stabler wrote on Apr 4, 2009 8:08 AM:

" Guess what this loser didn't do recently... she didn't show up for court! http://www.thebostonchannel.com/news/19090398/detail.html "

Jan wrote on Mar 12, 2009 9:17 PM:

" 071297 wrote on Mar 12, 2009 5:29 AM:

" I still think she is hot. "

----------------------

Actually, o7, she's a SOT. "

kbh1 wrote on Mar 12, 2009 4:10 PM:

" My heart goes out the Jeff's children. One of his daughter is the same age a Elizabeth she will not drive a car and has NO DAD "

ccardin wrote on Mar 12, 2009 1:41 PM:

" Floors: And as a family member of Jeffrey Cardin I can tell you that there was *NO* suicide note. AND this isn't the first time she's been in trouble: there was a run in with alcohol charges 9 days before the accident as well.

Being nice has nothing to do with making smart decisions and being held accountable for your actions.

Hitting a grown, standing man is a little hard to miss and she claimed to have not realized she hit anything at all. And, before you argue that point, they proved it was her car that killed him; her broken head light pieces and the pant transfer at the scene gave her away. (It w)ouldn't have happened if she hit something already on the ground. "

071297 wrote on Mar 12, 2009 5:29 AM:

" I still think she is hot. "

vladimir1 wrote on Mar 11, 2009 9:06 PM:

" How come all Norfolk kids suck? "

tmc2007 wrote on Mar 11, 2009 7:39 PM:

" "floors"- i knew Elizabeth from high school too, and I'm not sure why you think shes a "nice girl" ..whats your definition of nice girl? someone who drives drunk? or hits someone with their car and drives away? I'm sorry but you KNOW when you hit a good sized man with your car,and you would know it was not an animal.Also, Jeffery Cardin had never written a suicide note, you are just hearing rumors.


This girl needs to be locked up and should NEVER have a license again. "

reallyguys? wrote on Mar 11, 2009 6:38 PM:

" Where's the proof that he was "suicidal?" Sounds like smoke and mirrors to me. The guy was not suicidal. Give me a break. She's a murderer. Maybe the first time she made a mistake. Second time? She needs to be locked up. It's idiots who feel bad for her that continue this. Please don't breed, Floors, ok? Thanks! "

baseballfan wrote on Mar 11, 2009 5:48 PM:

" t "

skeptic wrote on Mar 11, 2009 5:00 PM:

" Sweet people can be drunks too. "

lee_from_lowell wrote on Mar 11, 2009 4:49 PM:

" ANOTHER irresponsible punk!...........
Lock her up,...and throw away the ROOM.
..please!! "

kathy flynn wrote on Mar 11, 2009 4:27 PM:

" Here we go with "but she's a good girl" and "it was a mistake" bs. Are you reading the paper for the first time? Do you know what the legal drinking age is in Mass.? She became combative, refused to answer questions .. sounds like a not so good girl to me. When are people going to stop coddling these idiots. "

floors wrote on Mar 11, 2009 4:08 PM:

" this is ridiculous. i knew this girl from high school. she is a very sweet girl and made a mistake drinking and driving this past weekend. as for the hit-and-run, do any of you know why she got away with it? its because two other people hit the man too. Also, they found out he was laying down own the road waiting to die. they found a suicide note. the hit-and-run wasn't her fault she thought she had hit an animal. none of you KNOW this girl. therefore, none of you have a right to decide what kind of fate she deserves. "

MrsAnthony wrote on Mar 11, 2009 2:19 PM:

" Here here Missy....well said! "

MrsAnthony wrote on Mar 11, 2009 2:18 PM:

" She is not a child. She is an adult. She has done this before and will do this again. Get her off the road and in to a program - at minimum. Let the justice system decide how she is punished.

And someone please wipe the smirk of her face. "

missy wrote on Mar 11, 2009 1:19 PM:

" I have an idea maybe we should get her birth mom
Out of local bar and send to rehab and jail wither
It starts at home! "

missy wrote on Mar 11, 2009 1:14 PM:

" I have an idea maybe we should get her birth mom
Out of the local bar and send her to rehab with
Elizabeth? It's starts at home ! "

liss wrote on Mar 11, 2009 11:28 AM:

" wow, she's a real winner. "

Jan wrote on Mar 11, 2009 10:41 AM:

" Get this stupid child off the road!

She should go live with the Duggars from the TLC program for the next few years, until she changes her ways. "

mmarcia wrote on Mar 11, 2009 10:09 AM:

" I hope the Cardin family sees some justice soon. She was 17, her alcohol problem could have been taken care of, but she's still out there, drunk, waiting to kill someone else. "

sunfan wrote on Mar 11, 2009 8:23 AM:

" As usual.....the chronic criminals keep getting away with their behavior until they kill or injure someone whose family can afford to sue her blind, and sue her enablers blind as well. The really sad thing is that criminals like this girl rarely injure themselves, only others. "

jackie1985 wrote on Mar 11, 2009 8:14 AM:

" I was one of the people that had found Mr. Cardin on the side of the rode that night three days before Christmas. I never forgot and never will. She needs to be punished to the fullest. He had a child my age-23. It was devastating! I have absolutely NO sympathy for her. If she's not punished she WILL drink and drive AGAIN and make the same fatal mistake she made Christmas of 2006. The Cardin family are still in my prayers. She disgusts me. "

themotherinme wrote on Mar 11, 2009 5:57 AM:

" If it is true about her step mother working in the policy dept she is a PROTECTED child. Her relationship to the WPD spills over into the Wrentham District Court. That's just the way it is. I think her protection may have run out however, folks. "

071297 wrote on Mar 11, 2009 5:52 AM:

" Is she single I think she is cute "

mia wrote on Mar 11, 2009 4:50 AM:

" Why on earth is she smiling in that booking photo???

Holy Crap. "

geofalcon007 wrote on Mar 11, 2009 12:14 AM:

" She should have been charged with vehicular homicide in the first case. She would have lost her license for 15 years. Maybe been on probation for more than 5 years. She needs a serious time out in jail now. She is lucky she did not kill again. "

agoodsource wrote on Mar 10, 2009 10:57 PM:

" you are correct. The adults do need to be punished too !! No one gets a guilty on an OUI at that court. All of the lawyers over there know that if you take a bench trial, the judge will dismiss the OUI and give them a guilty on the operating to endanger. This means that they will be found not have an OUI on there record. "

concernedjean wrote on Mar 10, 2009 10:48 PM:

" I do not think it is fair to say: "This is what is going to happen untill the Wrentham District Court starts to give these kids some consequenses for their actions. How many people have to die at the hands of a drunk underage teenager in this area?"

There have been several articles about adults who have had more than 7 DUI arrests and they all still have their license. Yes, teenagers need to be punished, however, there are adults who need to be punished too. "

agoodsource wrote on Mar 10, 2009 10:09 PM:

" Why is anyone supprised about this ? This is what is going to happen untill the Wrentham District Court starts to give these kids some consequenses for their actions. How many people have to die at the hands of a drunk underage teenager in this area ? I think that we can all agree that for some reason the parents have of these children have given up, and believe that the police should stop harrasing their children, but why will the court not do something about this. What would happen if this girl had killed someone who is connected to someone who is more important ? Then would she be in jail ? What if her step mother did not work for the Wrentham Police Dept. ? "

ccardin wrote on Mar 10, 2009 9:04 PM:

" I correct my previous statement: They concealed the fact that she was on drugs and on her cell phone when she killed Jeff on 12/21/06. Also they concealed the fact that she had been arrested only 9 days earlier for drinking 12/12/06. "

ccardin wrote on Mar 10, 2009 8:24 PM:

" http://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2006/12/23/wrentham_man_a_father_of_three_dies_in_hit_and_run/ "

ccardin wrote on Mar 10, 2009 8:09 PM:

" CO_Reader: The police found part of her broken headlight on the ground and the front end of her car was beaten up-indicating that she ran into something, not over it. What I think you are recalling is that his body was found on the ground with leaves on it. It's not a busy road and he was found a while after the accident had happened. She left the scene of the accident and didn't come home until the next day, making it impossible to know what she was under the infulence of when the accident happened.

Despite the hardships he was facing he was an upbeat man that loved his children and would never leave them. "

Phil wrote on Mar 10, 2009 6:58 PM:

" Her parents must be very proud!

Look my little girl made the paper

I guess when she gets her life straightened out. I will be seeing her at my shop installing a breathalyzer system if she wants to drive in MA. if this is her 2nd DWI

Add you to the list of the boozer losers. "

teacher wrote on Mar 10, 2009 5:24 PM:

" how do you know the man in the hit-and-run case was lying on the ground covered by leaves when she hit him??? Because she said so?? I wouldn't believe a word she said. I agree that she was loaded the night she hit him and that's why she didn't turn herself in. She "thought" she hit something? I think you'd know if you hit and killed a full grown man. "

attlebrained wrote on Mar 10, 2009 5:14 PM:

" Wow, probation for killing a guy hit and run, and you can still drive a couple years later. I would have thought you would loose your driving privileges a little longer than that. "

obear wrote on Mar 10, 2009 4:56 PM:

" Nice Smile in the booking photo. I guess getting arrested is pretty funny to some people. You know she was loaded the night she killed the man walking home, thats why she didn't stop. I hope she gets punished severly this time. "

CO_reader wrote on Mar 10, 2009 4:49 PM:

" I recall in that hit and run case from 2006, the guy laid in the road covered in leaves waiting to be run over. She should not be persecuted for someone else's suicide mission. As for the OUI, she made a bad choice. Luckily no one was hurt because of it. "

bmm wrote on Mar 10, 2009 4:39 PM:

" You should not judge someone unless you know the whole case. To tell the truth there are many adults that have no sense of responsibility themselves. So just don't blame the teenagers they do learn from people around them. We have to hope she will get the help she needs. God Bless Mr. Cardin. "

smp wrote on Mar 10, 2009 4:20 PM:

" Great example of teeenagers who have no sense of responsibility to even hold a drivers license. Just lock her up and throw away the keys now before she kills someone again. "

The Truth ! wrote on Mar 10, 2009 4:01 PM:

" p "

enuffalready wrote on Mar 10, 2009 3:47 PM:

" LOSER! "

realist wrote on Mar 10, 2009 3:05 PM:

" Probation is not unusual for a first offense hit and run. They couldn't prove alcohol or drugs were involved. "

mmarcia wrote on Mar 10, 2009 2:50 PM:

" Okj, I'll be the first to say it publicly:
PROBATION FOR A FATAL HIT AND RUN?????? "